Introduction
Ridge and River’s own Mads recently compared two of the shop’s most popular women’s fleeces, the Patagonia Better Sweater ¼ Zip and the Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan
After testing both around the Ridge and River store in Toledo, Ohio, Mads noticed distinct differences in fit, warmth, and mobility. Both pieces are high quality and versatile, but each serves a different purpose, one prioritizing breathability and movement, and the other focused on cozy warmth and comfort.
Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan: Breathable Performance and Freedom to Move
The Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan stands out as the more technical option. Mads tested it in store and was immediately impressed by its thoughtful construction and range of motion.
Fit and Feel
• Mads is 5’4” to 5’5” and wore a size small, which fit true to size.
• The fit allowed full movement through the arms and shoulders without restriction.
• Arc’teryx designs its sleeves with a slight curve rather than a straight cut, which enhances flexibility when bending or reaching.
This detail may seem minor, but it makes a noticeable difference when layering or staying active outdoors, perfect for hiking, climbing, or exploring spots like Oak Openings Metropark.
Fabric and Breathability
• Recycled polyester face fabric with a mesh interior around the torso for ventilation.
• Soft fleece lining in the sleeves and back for added warmth.
The mesh paneling helps regulate body temperature, preventing overheating during activity, something Mads appreciated while moving around the shop.
Pockets and Functionality
• Two external zip pockets that easily fit essentials.
• A small arm pocket suitable for small items like a car key or lip balm.
• No internal pockets, which Mads found to be a minor drawback for phone storage.
Best Use
The Covert Cardigan is ideal for active use, from climbing trips to cool weather camping. It is breathable, easy to layer, and offers excellent range of motion.
👉 Shop the Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan (Women’s)
Patagonia Better Sweater ¼ Zip: Cozy Comfort for Everyday Wear
The Patagonia Better Sweater is a timeless classic known for its warmth and comfort. Mads noted that while it is cozier overall, it does not offer quite the same mobility as the Arc’teryx.
Fit and Feel
• Mads also wore a size small in this piece, but the fit felt snugger, particularly across the back and shoulders.
• Raising the arms caused the sleeves to lift slightly, making it less ideal for movement heavy activities.
The Better Sweater’s fit is best suited for casual wear, such as cozy evenings around a campfire or a relaxed day downtown in Toledo.
Warmth and Lining
• Fully lined with soft fleece, creating a warm and cushy feel.
• Lacks mesh ventilation, so it retains heat better, great for lounging but less ideal for active pursuits.
Pockets and Design
• Two external zip pockets and two interior drop in pockets, perfect for phones or small items.
• A larger arm pocket than the Arc’teryx version, which can even fit an iPhone 17 snugly.
Best Use
The Better Sweater shines in casual, cold weather settings. It is perfect for staying warm during errands, campfire hangouts, or crisp Toledo mornings.
👉 Shop the Patagonia Better Sweater ¼ Zip (Women’s)
Final Thoughts: Which One Wins?
Both fleeces are built to last and deliver premium comfort. However, after wearing both, Mads found the Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan slightly ahead thanks to its
• Superior range of motion
• Breathable mesh construction
• True to size fit
The Patagonia Better Sweater remains a fantastic option for warmth and everyday wear, especially for those who prefer a snug, insulated feel. Sizing up may help achieve a looser, more flexible fit.
For anyone in Toledo, Ohio, both of these fleeces are available for in person try ons at Ridge and River’s stores.
📍 Visit us in store: Ridge and River Toledo Location
📍 Or stop by our Levis Commons store: Ridge and River Levis Commons Location
🎥 Watch the full video review here: YouTube – Patagonia Better Sweater vs Arc’teryx Covert Cardigan
Follow Ridge and River on Instagram and YouTube for more local gear reviews, adventure tips, and product insights from real users.
