Cotopaxi Allpa 50L vs. Patagonia Black Hole 55L: Which Travel Duffel Reigns Supreme?

Looking for the best travel duffel bag for your next adventure out of Toledo, Ohio? Whether you're heading to the airport, packing for a weekend camping trip, or just hauling gear across town, two heavy hitters stand out in the world of travel duffels: the Cotopaxi Allpa 50L Duffel and the Patagonia Black Hole 55L.

Zach from Ridge and River is back to break down the pros, cons, and real-world usability of both of these travel-focused duffel bags, helping you pick the right one for your lifestyle.

Cotopaxi Allpa 50L Duffel: Built for Organization

🛒 Shop the Cotopaxi Allpa 50L Duffel

Right out of the bag, the Allpa 50L impresses with how easily it packs and unpacks. It comes with a mesh stuff sack that’s flexible and easy to toss aside without needing a special folding technique. That alone makes it a favorite for quick transitions between packing and adventuring.

🔑 Key Features:

• TPU-coated waterproof top with a more traditional nylon bottom

• Chunky, backpack-style straps for comfortable carry

• Straps can be tucked away, making it airport-friendly

• Beefy grab handles and exterior loops for extra gear

• Side zip pocket with key leash (perfect for wallet or phone)

• Dedicated smell-proof compartment for dirty or wet gear

• Mesh interior pocket for smaller items like socks, toiletries, or sunglasses

Zach notes that the strap system is one of the only drawbacks, with a bit of a learning curve for new users. But if you value comfort and organization, the Allpa delivers in spades.

“This one definitely packs a punch if you like to get organized.”

Patagonia Black Hole 55L: Streamlined and Built to Last

🛒 Shop the Patagonia Black Hole 55L

Patagonia’s Black Hole series has been a staple in the travel world for years. The 55L version is slightly larger than the Allpa, but it leans more toward minimalism and durability.

🔑 Key Features:

• Fully recycled 900D ripstop polyester for unmatched toughness

• Storage sack doubles as the internal pocket

• Removable backpack straps that are easy to reattach

• Simple front pocket for fast access to essentials

• Large main compartment with a mesh divider on the top interior

• Velcro handle lock and traditional duffel carry straps

Zach points out that getting this bag into its storage form isn’t fun, but once it's out, it’s one of the most reliable bags you can own.

“This thing is a tried and true bag that’s been a popular duffel for decades… you can beat the heck out of this thing.”

Cotopaxi vs. Patagonia: Which One Should You Pick?

Final Thoughts from Zach

Both bags weigh in at 2 lbs 10 oz and are similarly priced in the $130–$200 range, depending on size and color. Here’s Zach’s breakdown:

• Go with the Cotopaxi Allpa 50L if you:

  • Want more compartments for clean and dirty gear

  • Prefer bold color options

  • Don't mind taking a little extra time with the straps

• Choose the Patagonia Black Hole 55L if you:

  • Want easy strap removal for TSA checks

  • Prefer simple packing with fewer pockets

  • Need a super tough, all-weather bag

🎒 Ready to Pack Smarter?

You can’t go wrong with either of these travel-ready duffels, but if you're still unsure, stop by and check them out in person. Nothing beats testing the fit and feel yourself.

📍 Visit us in-store: Ridge and River Toledo Location
💻 Prefer to shop online?

• Cotopaxi Allpa 50L Duffel

• Patagonia Black Hole 55L Duffel

💥 Use code YOUTUBE10 for 10% off your next order at ridgeandriver.com

👉 Follow us on Instagram for gear drops and outdoor tips: @ridgeandrivergear
👉 Subscribe on YouTube for reviews and expert insights: Ridge and River YouTube